Episode 90

full
Published on:

15th Sep 2025

75:: The one thing women DON'T need in their exercise handbags

Zone 2 Training: Do Women Really Need It?

Zone 2 training—steady-state cardio at 60–70% of your max heart rate—has been hailed as essential for endurance, fat burning, and longevity. But does the research actually apply to women?

In this episode, Dr. Kelsy Vick, board-certified Doctor of Physical Therapy and pelvic floor PT, breaks down the science of Zone 2 training and its role in women’s health, metabolism, and recovery. We’ll cover:

  • What Zone 2 training really is (and how to calculate it)
  • The cardiovascular and metabolic benefits for women
  • Hidden downsides: time inefficiency, cortisol stress, and limited bone/muscle benefits
  • Why women already have a natural advantage in fat oxidation and mitochondrial function
  • HIIT, SIT, and polarized training vs Zone 2—what’s more effective?
  • How to fit Zone 2 into your routine without guilt

If you’ve ever wondered whether you need 45–90 minutes of Zone 2 cardio five times a week, or if HIIT and strength training might be more efficient, this episode clears the air.

Tune in to learn how Zone 2 fits into your exercise handbag—and why it might be more of an accessory than an essential for women’s fitness.

loving the pod? click the follow button, & we'd love if you could leave a review! thank you x 1000 :)

subscribe to Laneless Ranger on Substack!

insta:: @dr.kelsyvickdpt & @lanelessranger

youtube:: @dr.kelsyvickdpt

tiktok:: @dr.kelsyvickdpt & @lanelessranger

Grab your very own Stakt Mat & Accessories for 10% off your order while also supporting the pod! (Thank you so much!):: https://shopstakt.com/?rave=DAW65UTUF4VNG7OV

Thorne Website:: https://s.thorne.com/Zgk7Y

My Thorne Dispensary & Recs:: https://www.thorne.com/u/drkelsyvickdpt

Message me for 35% off your Thorne orders!

00:00- 00:50 Intro

00:50- 02:12 Introduction to Exercise Handbag Series

02:13- 05:09 Understanding Zone Two Training

05:10- 08:49 Zone Two Training: Male vs. Female Physiology

08:50- 10:16 Polarized Training Model for Women

10:17- 10:43 Thorne

10:44- 12:19 Incorporating Zone Two and Polarized Training (part 2)

12:20- 12:46 Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Transcript
Speaker:

This next part of our exercise handbag

is going to deviate from the series

2

:

just a little bit because it might

not be as essential as we previously

3

:

thought, especially for women.

4

:

So let's clear the air a

bit on zone two training.

5

:

Specifically how zone two

training affects the female body.

6

:

Welcome back to Wellness, fix the Pod.

7

:

I'm your host, Dr.

8

:

Kelsey Vic, a board

certified orthopedic Dr.

9

:

Physical therapy and a pelvic

floor physical therapist.

10

:

And this new series we've been

doing throughout September.

11

:

I'm calling the exercise handbag

series because we are talking about

12

:

some of the essentials to include

in your exercise handbag, where

13

:

we all have different handbags.

14

:

We all have different styles of handbags

that we enjoy, that we gravitate

15

:

towards, just like we have different

forms of exercise that we might

16

:

gravitate towards, but the essentials

in our handbag, the essentials in our

17

:

exercise routine, especially as women.

18

:

Should be pretty similar.

19

:

We have our phones, our keys, our wallets,

just like in our exercise handbag, we also

20

:

have some of the essentials that we want

as foundations in our exercise routine.

21

:

So our first two essentials we

covered were high intensity interval

22

:

training slash sprint interval

training, and then also jump training.

23

:

High intensity interval training.

24

:

Super controversial.

25

:

So we dive into that in that episode.

26

:

And then jump training is

27

:

The secret sister that no

one really talks about.

28

:

So we chat about jump training and how

beneficial it is for us as women in

29

:

the previous episode and this week.

30

:

Again, deviating a little bit talking

about zone two training and why it might

31

:

not be as essential as we previously

thought, especially for women.

32

:

So first of all, what

is zone two training?

33

:

Zone two training is exercising at about

60 to 70% of your max heart rate or a max

34

:

effort for a prolonged period of time.

35

:

As a reminder, in order to

calculate your max heart rate,

36

:

just do two 20 minus your age.

37

:

So for someone who's 20

years old, two 20 minus 20.

38

:

Estimated max heart rate would

be about 200 beats per minute.

39

:

So exercising in that 60 to 70%

range of that heart rate zone

40

:

will be your zone two training.

41

:

Another way to look at it that we were

taught in school is that you can maintain

42

:

a conversation but you can't sing.

43

:

So if you're able to speed walk and

talk but not sing, that is that zone

44

:

two moderate intensity training.

45

:

When it comes to zone two training, most

of the research done on zone two training

46

:

has been done on men, which is why I

wanted to dive into this topic today.

47

:

Historically speaking, it's it's been

recommended to get about 45 to 90

48

:

minutes of zone two training five times

a week, but a lot of that research

49

:

has been done on the male body.

50

:

so we'll dive into how that

contrasts with the female body.

51

:

What are the benefits of zone two

training from an overarching perspective?

52

:

One, of course, cardiovascular

benefits, heart health is huge, and

53

:

zone two really does help with that.

54

:

We also have the benefits of fat

oxidation and improved metabolism, and

55

:

then we also can use zone two as active

recovery and mental health benefits of.

56

:

So those are the overarching

benefits of zone two training

57

:

for both men and for women.

58

:

So what are some reasons we might

not wanna do zone two training and

59

:

might wanna choose another form of

cardiovascular exercise to sort one of

60

:

the cons is time inefficiency and guilt.

61

:

It takes a good amount of time to

exercise for as long as we need to.

62

:

At 60 to 70% of our max heart rate,

it's pretty easy to get to that 60, 70%.

63

:

So in order to get those benefits.

64

:

That we talked about, the

cardiovascular benefits, the

65

:

metabolic benefits, all of that.

66

:

We need to exercise for a very long

period of time, and someone might feel

67

:

a little bit guilty not reaching that 90

minutes, five times a week recommendation

68

:

that we've historically adopted.

69

:

there's also limited stimulus for

adaptation, especially as we age.

70

:

It is not hard enough exercise to help

with muscle mass or bone Mineral density,

71

:

which we've already discussed, are

both things that we want to focus on,

72

:

especially as we age, and it's not easy

enough to be active recovery, so it falls

73

:

in this sort of like gray middle zone.

74

:

With prolonged exercise, we can

have sustained cortisol increases.

75

:

So if you're someone who has a high

baseline level of cortisol anyways,

76

:

whether through work, stress, family

stress, life stress, just you're a

77

:

chronic zone two exerciser where you're

doing that 90 minutes five times a week

78

:

at 60 to 70% of your max heart rate,

you can have elevated cortisol levels

79

:

for a more prolonged period of time.

80

:

So extended moderate intensity exercise,

especially when combined with other

81

:

stressors in life, can lead to elevated

cortisol levels, especially in women.

82

:

Now let's zoom in a little bit more

specifically on why the female physiology

83

:

differs from the male physiology when

it comes to zone two training women

84

:

in general, as we mentioned in the

first essential series, have natural.

85

:

superior mitochondrial

function than men do,

86

:

we have more oxidative, meaning they

use oxygen type one skeletal muscle

87

:

fibers that have a high mitochondrial

density and we actually have about

88

:

a third greater mitochondrial

respiration as women compared to men.

89

:

Women are also much more

metabolically flexible than men.

90

:

We switch between.

91

:

Utilizing carbs and fats

as fuel quicker than men.

92

:

So a lot of the time men will do zone

two training to switch from that glucose,

93

:

that carbohydrate fuel utilization to fat.

94

:

For fat loss.

95

:

As women, we are actually really

good at switching, and so we don't

96

:

necessarily need as long of that

time at that moderate intensity

97

:

to switch to that fat utilization.

98

:

We do it relatively

quickly compared to a male.

99

:

We're able to oxidize more fat and

less carbs than men during prolonged

100

:

exercise at a similar intensity.

101

:

We maintain a better cellular

energy homeostasis during exercise

102

:

stress, and we have better built-in

fat burning efficiency, which

103

:

is basically that fat oxidation.

104

:

We have a greater abundance of fatty

acid transporters, meaning we're

105

:

better able to use those fatty acids.

106

:

Because we have more of that transporter

to utilize those fatty acids as energy.

107

:

We also have more stored fat within

our muscles, which is easier to access

108

:

compared to fat stored in other places.

109

:

And so we're better able to tap

in to the fat, stored in muscle

110

:

to utilize that for energy.

111

:

And we have better mechanisms

for utilizing fat as fuel too.

112

:

So because of our.

113

:

Mitochondrial density

being higher than men.

114

:

We also have more metabolic

flexibility able to switch

115

:

between carbohydrates and fats.

116

:

Zone two might not be as necessary for us.

117

:

Since a few of the primary pros and

reasons to do zone two training is

118

:

to train the mitochondria and utilize

fat for body composition changes.

119

:

The fact that our bodies are already

structured to do that makes zone two may

120

:

be less of a priority for us as women.

121

:

It's not that it's bad for us, not at all.

122

:

It's just that when building our

exercise handbags of essentials.

123

:

The essentials we need in our routine,

why would we include something that

124

:

takes so much time and that our body is

already naturally adapted for, rather than

125

:

incorporating some of the other essentials

that we actually need, like high intensity

126

:

interval training and sprint interval

training that our bodies aren't as

127

:

set up for as our male counterparts.

128

:

High intensity interval training and

sprint interval training have also

129

:

been shown to be more beneficial in the

cardiovascular and metabolic realms.

130

:

With less of a time commitment.

131

:

So overall it's about bang for your buck.

132

:

If you really enjoy

zone two cardio, do it.

133

:

By all means, it's wonderful as long as

you have the appropriate cool down and

134

:

the appropriate recovery in between.

135

:

Zone two is great, and I'm not

discouraging at all, but if we're really

136

:

trying to build that exercise handbags of

purely essentials that we can do across

137

:

the board, it might be better bang for

your buck to incorporate another form

138

:

of cardiovascular and metabolic based

activities like high intensity interval

139

:

training and sprint interval training.

140

:

So there are exceptions, of course.

141

:

If you're training for something

long duration, lower intensity, or

142

:

moderate intensity, like a marathon,

of course you need to do zone training.

143

:

Specificity of training does matter, so

if you're training for something that

144

:

is moderate intensity, long duration,

you are going to want to include zone

145

:

two training in your current routine

for that training block, for that race

146

:

or event that you're training for.

147

:

As I was researching for this

episode, I came across another sort

148

:

of training mindset when it comes to

cardiovascular training that I thought

149

:

would be interesting to you guys too.

150

:

It basically talks about polarized

training for cardiovascular training where

151

:

if you can think of polarized opinions or.

152

:

Polar opposites.

153

:

They're on either side of the spectrum.

154

:

So this research argues that especially

for women, it's really good if we spend

155

:

the majority of our time in that black and

white zone on either end of the spectrum,

156

:

not as much in that gray area, not as

much in that moderate intensity area.

157

:

They advocate for spending time on either

side of the extreme, so 75 to 80% lower

158

:

intensity training, less than 10% of

moderate intensity training like zone

159

:

two, so not as much of that gray area,

and then 15 to 20% high intensity training

160

:

mixed, of course, with strength training.

161

:

And so thinking of that polarized training

model being super beneficial for women,

162

:

knowing that we're spending time on

either sides of the extremes and not as

163

:

much in that gray area, that middle zone.

164

:

So there are a lot of studies showing

benefit in the twenties and thirties,

165

:

forties and fifties, and 50 plus

age ranges for women utilizing this

166

:

polarized training, especially with

improving your metabolism, improving

167

:

fat utilization, body fat reduction,

and improved power and endurance.

168

:

So thinking of that as an alternative to

this prolonged, moderate intensity work,

169

:

working on either side of that spectrum

with that polarized training model.

170

:

So how do we incorporate it

into our exercise handbag?

171

:

Knowing what we know now and knowing

that zone two is maybe a little bit

172

:

more optional than what we previously

thought, especially for women.

173

:

If you wanna include zone training

because you enjoy it, not necessarily

174

:

training for anything specific, limit it

to about one to two sessions per week.

175

:

You can also use it for active

recovery in between your main sessions.

176

:

It shouldn't be the primary focus of your

cardiovascular training, but of course

177

:

you can use it for mental health reasons.

178

:

If you wanna try more of a polarized

training model, exercising in

179

:

those black and white zones and

not as much in that gray zone.

180

:

Shoot for 30 minutes of walking each day.

181

:

Again, that's that lower intensity range.

182

:

And then 15 to 25 minute high

intensity interval training

183

:

sessions about two to three times

per week on non-consecutive days.

184

:

As we talked about in our essentials

course in our first episode of the

185

:

Exercise Handbag Essentials series.

186

:

And if you do want to exercise in that

zone two range because you enjoy it,

187

:

because it's easy to do with a friend.

188

:

Always think, am I in zone two?

189

:

am I able to carry on a

conversation without singing?

190

:

That's a really good gauge as

to know whether or not you truly

191

:

are in that zone two range.

192

:

So jogging with friends, cycling around

your neighborhood at a leisurely place.

193

:

Dance, cardio, sculpt flow

classes, Pilates flow classes.

194

:

Always you can incorporate zone two

training if you enjoy it, if it's

195

:

something that you really love to do.

196

:

Knowing that it's not necessarily

essential and definitely not a

197

:

foundational element for our exercise

handbags, especially as women.

198

:

I know that probably

surprised some of you.

199

:

I hope you enjoyed this episode.

200

:

I hope you learned more why our bodies as

women might not respond as well to zone

201

:

two training as men or might not need

it as much as our male counterparts do.

202

:

But I hope you learned something.

203

:

I hope you enjoyed this episode.

204

:

I hope you're enjoying this series so far.

205

:

I'd love to hear from you guys to see

what you've learned and how you're

206

:

incorporating it into your own routines.

207

:

But thank you guys so much for listening,

and I'll see you guys again on the next

208

:

episode of Wellness Fixes of the Pod.

Show artwork for Wellness Big Sis: The Pod

About the Podcast

Wellness Big Sis: The Pod
For the girl with a physiologic repulsion to the phrase “stay in your lane.” The one whose curiosity often gets the best of her, and who’d rather learn something new than pretend she already knows it. Her podcast and media feed jumps from culture to business to fashion to tech to interiors to food, and she wouldn’t have it any other way.
She has friends who each know a piece of her, and only a few who get the whole picture. This is a place for the whole picture.
She looks at the world and sees opportunity everywhere, with no lanes in sight. If that sounds like you, you’re in the right place.
@lanelessranger
@dr.kelsyvickdpt
https://lanelessranger.substack.com/

About your host

Profile picture for Kelsy Vick

Kelsy Vick

Wellness Big Sis: The Pod (By Maven Media) includes wellness girl chats by host, Kelsy Vick, a board-certified orthopedic Doctor of Physical Therapy. Join us as we learn about our female bodies and all aspects of wellness, creating a sisterhood of empowered wellness big sisters... without the clothes-stealing ;)

sign up for the free Smart Girl newspaper: https://thesmartgirlnewspaper.beehiiv.com/
@wellnessbigsispod
@dr.kelsyvickdpt
@bymavenmedia
elaa-wellness.com
@elaa_wellness
@dr.kelsyvickdpt